Windermere Reserve Homes for Sale

About Windermere Reserve Neighborhood

Windermere Reserve sits on the east side of Lake Down in the heart of Windermere's 34786 ZIP code, with its main loop street — Horizon Circle — running off Conroy-Windermere Road approximately a mile from the Town of Windermere historic district. The neighborhood is a small gated community — roughly 30 custom estate homes total — built between approximately 1993 and 1999 by various custom builders. Unlike the production luxury developments that have dominated Windermere construction since 2010, Windermere Reserve was built one home at a time on oversized lots, and the resulting streetscape is a mix of architectural styles rather than a single builder template.

Homes here typically range from approximately 3,400 to 4,500 square feet with four to six bedrooms, three-car garages, and barrel tile roofs. Lots are large enough — three-quarter acre to well over an acre — that most owners have private pools and there is room for tennis, basketball, or sport courts. Nine homes have direct frontage and access to Lake Down, part of the Butler Chain of Lakes. Mature shade trees throughout the neighborhood reflect three decades of growth.

The location is the neighborhood's strongest asset. The entrance opens onto Conroy-Windermere Road with The Grove at Isleworth directly north across the road — meaning groceries, dining, and services are a 30-second drive. Olympia High School is approximately a half mile north at 4301 S Apopka-Vineland Road. Downtown Windermere and Town Square are about a mile northwest; Fernwood Park, with the Lake Butler public boat ramp, is a similar distance.

Windermere Reserve Location & Connections

Windermere Reserve is positioned at one of Windermere's most strategic intersections — where Conroy-Windermere Road meets S Apopka-Vineland Road. Conroy-Windermere is the town's main east-west artery, running from downtown Windermere out to MetroWest and I-4. S Apopka-Vineland connects north to Apopka and south to The Grove at Isleworth and the Sand Lake Road / Restaurant Row corridor. The location offers commute access in every direction without requiring residents to drive through downtown traffic.

The neighborhood backs onto the Lake Down shoreline on its western edge, with nine homes enjoying direct lake frontage and Butler Chain access. The remaining homes sit on interior streets with mature canopy and pool yards.

Windermere Reserve Amenities & Lifestyle

Windermere Reserve offers a distinctly residential-quiet character despite sitting at one of Windermere's most active intersections. The gated entry, oversized lots, and mature canopy create the privacy of an inland luxury community, while the position next to The Grove and Olympia High means owners walk or bike to retail and schools that residents of more remote luxury enclaves drive to.

For lake-active households, the nine Lake Down lakefront homes have private dock potential and direct boat access to all eleven lakes of the Butler Chain of Lakes. Non-lakefront residents are five minutes from Fernwood Park's public boat ramp on Lake Butler.

How Windermere Reserve Compares

Windermere Reserve occupies an unusual middle position in the 34786 luxury market. It is gated and small enough to feel exclusive, but it is not a guard-gated golf community on the scale of Isleworth or Keene's Pointe. Its strongest comparable peers are other small NE-Windermere lakefront-adjacent gated communities of similar age and lot size.

Windermere Reserve HOA & CDD Information

Windermere Reserve has an active homeowners association that maintains the gated entry, common areas, and community standards for the approximately 30 homes. Because the neighborhood was platted in the early 1990s — well before the Florida CDD model became common in master-planned communities — there is no Community Development District debt attached to homes here.

Frequently Asked Questions